Starbucks, Philadelphia settle with 2 black men in ‘trespassing’ case
Money can be a powerful symbol—even when it’s a small figure.
Many are remarking on the $1 apiece settlement that two African-American
men received from the City of Philadelphia after they were arrested while
waiting for a friend at Starbucks. Beyond that, though, the city is setting
up a $200,000 fund for grants benefitting young entrepreneurs of color.
While much media attention is going to the city’s actions, Starbucks has
quietly agreed to pay the Donte Robinson and Rashon Nelson an undisclosed
sum. Starbucks also hopes to partner with the men to address cultural
issues around race in the community as it tries to repair its damaged
Starbucks wrote in a press release:
After constructive conversations, Donte Robinson, Rashon Nelson and Kevin
Johnson, ceo of Starbucks Coffee Company (NASDAQ:SBUX) reached an agreement
earlier this week.
The agreement between the parties stemming from the
events in Philadelphia
on April 12 will include a financial settlement as well as continued
listening and dialogue between the parties and specific action and
Starbucks sought to show how it would work with Nelson and Robinson to
improve experiences for black customers in its stores and in the community.
“I want to thank Donte and Rashon for their willingness to reconcile,” said
Kevin Johnson, ceo Starbucks. “I welcome the opportunity to begin a
relationship with them to share learnings and experiences. And Starbucks
will continue to take actions that stem from this incident to repair and
reaffirm our values and vision for the kind of company we want to be.”
The company has also pledged to help Robinson and Nelson with their
In an April 18 interview with “CBS This Morning,” Starbucks executive chairman, Howard Schultz, said he hoped to work with
Nelson and Robinson and use Starbucks’s resources to advise and support
their business ventures.
“We will provide them with a foundation of learning and provide them with
an opportunity to be part of our company either directly or indirectly as a
result of this situation,” Schultz told co-host Gayle King.
As for the accord with the city, The Washington Post reported:
“This was an incident that evoked a lot of pain in our city, pain that
would’ve resurfaced over and over again in protracted litigation, which
presents significant legal risks and high financial and emotional costs for
everyone involved,” Philadelphia Mayor Jim Kenney said in a statement.
Kenney said Nelson and Robinson approached the city as partners “to make
something positive come of this.”
Funds for the $200,000 program will come from the city’s Finance Department
budget, Dunn said. The city, Nelson and Robinson will work together on
developing a committee to award the grants.
On Twitter, some thought Nelson and Robinson should have gotten more than a
symbolic single dollar from the city.
I’m still lost. Even if Starbucks cuts them a check separately i don’t understand a $1 settlement. Like wtf is that accomplishing? RT @wildmanjones: Two dudes from Philly literally settled for a dollar and a dream
— Dii STATE G (@GNAST_718) May 2, 2018
I’m hating this Starbucks settlement story. We always want to see black people taking the upper road when corporations and citizens dehumanize us. And people applaud it. Make them PAY!!!
— Komorebi #BΔK (@JanvierNoir) May 3, 2018
Others saw the move as a positive response to an ugly incident:
These guys are what’s good about America. They took 1 dollar for a settlement and created a 200k fund for young entrepreneurs of all color. They took something racist and created something special. https://t.co/JzGTMb8bSb
— Kenny Stuth Jr. (@McStuthy) May 2, 2018
Bravo to Rashon Nelson and Donte Robinson for accepting a symbolic $1 settlement from the city of Philadelphia, which is also donating $200,000 to a program to support young entrepreneurs. Their dedication to future generations is an inspiration for us all https://t.co/Rugvj3vpcx
— Jackie Speier (@RepSpeier) May 2, 2018
And now to distract from Kanye craziness…
BREAKING: Black men arrested at Starbucks settle with Philadelphia for $1 each and a city pledge of $200K for young entrepreneurs.
p.s. If you don’t see the genius in this settlement, you’re not looking at the bigger picture.
— Timothy Ayers (@timothy_ayers) May 3, 2018
Most media attention has gone to the symbolic agreement with the city and not Starbucks’ undisclosed settlement amount. There has even been some confusion, with some readers conflating the two settlements.
So the $1 “settlement “ that the Black men arrested at the Philadelphia Starbucks was with the city of Philly. They might have made a separate settlement agreement with Starbucks, that has not been disclosed yet
— Tariq Nasheed (@tariqnasheed) May 2, 2018
How would you advise Starbucks to talk about its settlement, PR Daily readers?