How to Make Your Premium WordPress Theme Competitive

When I started my career as premium WordPress theme
developer, making a theme competitive was not such a challenge. In those days you could create a
premium WordPress theme with a predefined simple slider, no page builder at all, having hundreds of demos was unnecessary, WooCommerce compatibility wasn’t particularly important, neither was bbPress or any other major plugin, and you could still look forward to decent sales numbers without any promotion just
because your theme was visually appealing and qualitatively good enough among its peers. I once witnessed how a single theme gave an author elite status in just three months, without any complex marketing or promotion.

Envato’s coveted Elite Program

But, as always happens, times have changed. Today, creating a competitive premium WordPress theme is a genuine challenge. Competition is tough, customers demand more, and technology continues to race forward unabated. The market has
grown though; more and more customers prefer WordPress as their CMS platform. According to
, WordPress powers 30% of all websites on the
Internet, even taking into account those without a content management system (CMS) or with
a custom-coded CMS. And if you limit the data set to only websites with a known
CMS, WordPress’ market share becomes even more dominant.

So how can we succeed nowadays in the WordPress premium theme
market? Here are my main thoughts, which I’ll go into in more detail shortly:

  1. Creating WordPress themes for sell is not always fun,
    it is real business. If you want to sell WordPress themes on a regular
    basis, you should treat it seriously, rather than it being a hobby. Creating
    premium WordPress themes from time to time, when you are in a good mood, is unlikely to be a
    succesful business strategy. So the first component of developing competitive premium
    WordPress theme is having a clear business
  2. The second important component is quality. Without adhering to quality standards your theme will
    not even pass the review stage.
  3. Marketing, marketing, and (one more time) marketing! Without marketing of any kind you will find it difficult to generate solid sales. A high quality theme which isn’t promoted in any way won’t generate as many sales as an inferior theme which is marketed well.

Let’s look at these in more detail.

1. Have a Clear Business Strategy

Your business strategy begins with determining at what stage in your theme development career you are. Perhaps you’ve just registered a new account with Themeforest, or maybe you’re already selling themes,
but you want to take your sales to the next level. If you are selling on Themeforest and
are perfectly happy with your results, this article is not for you! GLWS (good luck with sales) as you’ll hear them say in the Themeforest community!

Be Patient

You may have to hone your craft before selling anything. Don’t be afraid to spend six months educating yourself before creating something to sell.

Find a Niche

Research which niche you’ll build your theme around. Many categories in the WordPress arena (such as Corporate, Creative, Blog Magazine, and eCommerce) are heavily saturated, which will make success in these areas more challenging.

Multipurpose WordPress themes
The highly competitive Multipurpose niche

Reduce Theme Creation Time

Ideally, from
planning, design, development, testing, submitting, and approval it should not take
more than 30 days. You won’t have any control over the review process, but at the time of writing the review
process and resubmission process take 24 hours. 

You can track the
review process time for any product on the Envato marketplaces. Bookmark
this link
and check it each day. If the review process is delayed don’t panic, do not waste your time in Themeforest forums; instead switch to your next project and be patient.


Split the Work

If you don’t have a team and plan to do both design and
development by yourself, make sure that you are competent enough in both areas, otherwise I highly recommend you find a good designer, or a suitable approved
design. If you browse the PSD category on Themeforest you will see thousands of approved files. There’s no reason you can’t cooperate with
these designers. Take time to examine designs you like, and if you find something you’re interested in, you have a couple of courses of action for collaboration:

  • Development and theme support from you (60-70%
    of revenue, if your skills are suitably good) and approved design from
    designer (30-40%).
  • 50%/50% if your WordPress skills are intermediate.
  • Single payment for conversion rights (the price
    depends on the item, but you might find you’re looking at about $800-$1500). Contact the Envato team to make them aware of your cooperation.

This is common practice in theme development, so don’t
be surprised if a designer you reach out to already has an arrangement with someone else. Make sure you have value to offer, otherwise concentrate on 100% completely independent

Your Competitors

A good business strategy starts with good research. Take
time to examine the strongest of your competitors. Start with the creators behind the top-selling themes in your chosen category. Importantly though, whilst these themes are the top-sellers, do not fall into the trap of emulating their product logic, their aesthetic,
their demo presentations. Try to understand what factors (excluding advertisement) make these themes top-sellers. Usually, you will see older themes in
the top list of your category; these will be the trailblazers, so understanding
how they are created and organized is one of your main tasks.

Do not
measure the category potential purely by the top-selling themes. Instead, look at sales from newly added themes in your preferred category. If you see thousands of sales from the top-selling theme each week, but single-digit sales from the newly added themes, you should
expect your initial sales to match the lower numbers.

Another thing which is worth taking into account: if you
examine the changelog of the older top-selling themes, you will see that they were likely much simpler packages when they were launched. The multitude of what have become standard features, like page builders, Revolution sliders, demos, WooCommerce computability etc.,
will have been added over the course of time. This steady improvement, unfortunately, isn’t an approach you can afford to take nowadays!

2. Aim For High

I’m all too familiar with the
standard “Hard Reject” message from Themeforest’s review team–it hurts! The only way not to experience this pain again and again is to focus on quality. There are several
components to consider:

Focus on Design

Everything starts from design; be creative and unique. When you start your research process, examine your
competitors, but do not copy them, do not copy elements, colors, or structure. With each of these the risk of hard rejection increases. 

If you doubt your design, consider submitting a PSD version to Themeforest.
In about five days you will get an answer. If your design is good enough, you’re on the right track to avoid a hard reject.

Stand out design
Outstanding design will help your theme.. stand out

Test Technical Quality

Technical quality can be achieved by examining the WordPress
theme submitting requirements. Carefully examine all the content–your theme must conform 100%. New requirements state that theme authors must pass the Envato
Theme Check
without any issues, along with the basic WordPress
Theme Unit Test
. So before submission make sure you run these tests.

Weigh up Added Features 

Nowadays including premium plugins in theme–making theme “3rd party plugin compatible”–is a rule, rather than an exception. I highly recommend you include WPBakery Page Builder ($250 extended license) or King Composer (free) as your
page builder. Revolution Slider ($125 extended license) or Layer
($125 extended license) are ideal for your theme slider. All these
plugins can be packaged with your theme for free. For each theme you develop you need to buy a separate extended license. 

Slider Revolution
The Slider Revolution WP plugin has seen over 250,000 sales

Also consider adding extra more features to your
themes, making them compatible with popular plugins like WPML, BBpress, Buddypress,
WooCommerce and so on. Which of these you cater for highly depends on the category of your item.

Optimize Theme Demos

Remember the important rule: if the customer does not see your theme’s feature, those features may as well not exist. Do your potential buyers know that:

  • the theme has multiple header versions,
  • it has unlimited colors,
  • it has a boxed or framed version,
  • it has multiple sliders,
  • it has different footer variations,
  • it has a RTL version?

Even if your design is brilliantly unique, your
code is all-powerful, but your demo is poor, your theme still won’t reach its potential. Do make sure test your demos on as many screen
sizes as possible, because different users will have different experiences when viewing your
demos with different devices.

Invest in Hosting Performance

If you plan to make WordPress theme development your
business, you need business server solutions. Hosts like HostGator, GoDaddy are almost certainly not the best option for your business. I recommend you buy a VPS (Virtual Private Server), or Cloud
solution from specialized companies like Kinsta, or MediaTemple (check out the Themeforest hosting page for discount codes). 

However, if you are
competent at server configuration and SSH, I highly recommend you buy a clean
server/cloud solution and install or configure your own server. This is a cheaper option. If you’re interested in learning how this all works, let me know in the
comments section; if there’s demand I will write a
separate tutorial with step by step instructions.

Before creating a theme production demo, make sure your
hosting server meets the WordPress
minimum requirnments
. The most important being:

  • PHP version at least 7, ideally 7.2+
  • HTTPS certificate

If you want to speed up your theme demo performance, I highly recommend you use a CDN, especially given the global distribution of Envato’s customer base. From my experience a CDN can reduce WordPress demo sites’ loading times by 50%.

You might also like
Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.